top of page

Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson faced varying responses during confirmation hearings

The two major political parties clashed in the hearings as one presented a line of questioning worthy of a qualified judge while the other used false equivalencies to damage the reputation of Jackson.

Analysis by Matthew Royer, News Editor

The Senate Judiciary Committee will vote on April 4 to advance Ketanji Brown Jackson’s nomination to the full chamber of the U.S. Senate. (Photo courtesy of Senate Judiciary Committee)

Ketanji Brown Jackson. A historical candidate. The first Black woman presented for confirmation to the land’s highest court.


The hearings, however, made history in another way.


Earlier this year under a nation still very divided, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer announced his intent to retire, opening his seat on the bench. With three new jurists added to the court over the last administration, this soon-to-be vacancy allowed President Joe Biden to keep his campaign promise in nominating a Black woman to the top court that has swayed conservatively over the past four years.


The president’s choice to replace the oldest court justice was Jackson, who had recently been confirmed to replace Attorney General Merrick Garland on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia District.


The Harvard graduate would become the first former public defender on the U.S. Supreme Court upon confirmation by the U.S. Senate, but confirmation is not the simple process it once was. The court has been politicized by special interests, like conservative thinktank The Federalist Society, according to The Examiner, has funneled campaign funds and donations to politicians to represent their train of thought.


On March 22, Jackson took the traditional oath in front of the Senate Judiciary Committee, and a line of questioning began from Republicans and Democrats alike.


In her opening statement, the 51-year-old delivered a message that was composed and important in acknowledging her forthcoming role on the court.


“I have been a judge for nearly a decade now, and I take that responsibility and my duty to be independent very seriously,” said Jackson, according to CNN. “I decide cases from a neutral posture. I evaluate the facts, and I interpret and apply the law to the facts of the case before me, without fear or favor, consistent with my judicial oath.


While Jackson set a solemn tone for the hearings, Capitol Hill quickly erupted into chaos.


Republican committee members promptly turned the hearing into an opportunity to verbally attack their Democratic colleagues. Senators such as Lindsey Graham (R-SC), Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Mike Lee (R-UT) used their time to rehash the discussion of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s confirmation hearings of 2018 in which Democratic Senators focused on allegations of sexual assault and later the lack of executive focus on the FBI’s investigation into the claims.


On day two of the hearings, any hope for a civilized day was thrown down the steps of Capitol Hill. The court of appeals judge was vehemently asked questions that Jackson made sure to point out “doesn't come up in my work.” These included opening wounds on ‘critical-race theory’ and her lack of a set philosophy in deciding cases, the former a focus of the Republican Party’s culture war agenda entering the midterm elections in November.


Acknowledging her constraints as a judge, Biden’s nominee set her beliefs straight in response to the questioning.


“I am acutely aware that as a judge in our system, I have limited power,” said Jackson, according to CSPAN. “I am trying in every case to stay in my lane.”


Democratic senators used their allocated time during the four days to ask the nominee about her judicial and educational background, experiences as a mother and decisions in significant cases going in front of the court, such as capital punishment and abortion rights. However, judiciary committee members also used their time to defend Jackson against the “unfair” line of questioning.


Senators Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Cory Booker (D-NJ) each took ample opportunity to praise the judge for her humility and effort during what could be described as a barrage or an ambush at times. On day three, Booker erupted in what The Atlantic has described as an “impassioned” defense of Jackson.


"You are my harbinger of hope,” said Booker, noting the historical impact of the nomination. “This country's getting better and better and better. And when that final vote happens, and you ascend onto the highest court in the land, I'm going to rejoice. And I'm going to tell you right now, the greatest country in the world, the United States of America, will be better because of you."


The Senate Judiciary Committee will vote on April 4 to advance Jackson’s nomination to the full chamber of the U.S. Senate, where, according to ABC Chicago, Senate Majority Whip Durbin feels “hopeful” his colleagues will confirm her on April 8.

23 Comments


BFVY IRTO
BFVY IRTO
Feb 10

AV在线看 AV在线看;

自拍流出 自拍流出;

国产视频 国产视频;

日本无码 日本无码;

动漫肉番 动漫肉番;

吃瓜专区 吃瓜专区;

SM调教 SM调教;

ASMR ASMR;

国产探花 国产探花;

强奸乱伦 强奸乱伦;

Like

BFVY IRTO
BFVY IRTO
Feb 09

AV在线看 AV在线看;

自拍流出 自拍流出;

国产视频 国产视频;

日本无码 日本无码;

动漫肉番 动漫肉番;

吃瓜专区 吃瓜专区;

SM调教 SM调教;

ASMR ASMR;

国产探花 国产探花;

强奸乱伦 强奸乱伦;

Like

WKDU TRBD
WKDU TRBD
Jan 06

代发外链 提权重点击找我;

谷歌蜘蛛池 谷歌蜘蛛池;

Fortune Tiger…

Fortune Tiger…

谷歌权重提升/ 谷歌权重提升;

谷歌seo 谷歌seo;

谷歌霸屏 谷歌霸屏

蜘蛛池 蜘蛛池

谷歌快排 谷歌快排

Google外链 Google外链

谷歌留痕 谷歌留痕

Gái Gọi…

Gái Gọi…

Dịch Vụ…

谷歌霸屏 谷歌霸屏

负面删除 负面删除

币圈推广 币圈推广

Google权重提升 Google权重提升

Google外链 Google外链

google留痕 google留痕

Like

BFVY IRTO
BFVY IRTO
Jan 06

代发外链 提权重点击找我;

蜘蛛池 蜘蛛池;

谷歌马甲包/ 谷歌马甲包;

谷歌霸屏 谷歌霸屏;

谷歌霸屏 谷歌霸屏

蜘蛛池 蜘蛛池

谷歌快排 谷歌快排

Google外链 Google外链

谷歌留痕 谷歌留痕

Gái Gọi…

Gái Gọi…

Dịch Vụ…

谷歌霸屏 谷歌霸屏

负面删除 负面删除

币圈推广 币圈推广

Google权重提升 Google权重提升

Google外链 Google外链

google留痕 google留痕

Like

jejf afpg
jejf afpg
Dec 31, 2024

代发外链 提权重点击找我;

谷歌蜘蛛池 谷歌蜘蛛池;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Fortune Tiger Slots Fortune…

谷歌权重提升/ 谷歌权重提升;

谷歌seo 谷歌seo;

מכונות ETPU מכונות ETPU;

Машини ETPU Машини ETPU

ETPU-Maschinen ETPU-Maschinen

EPS-машины EPS-машины

ЭПП-машины ЭПП-машины� بي يو

ETPU maşınları ETPU maşınları

ETPUマシン ETPUマシン

ETPU 기계 ETPU 기계

Like
Screenshot 2025-02-18 at 11.56.31 AM.png
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Twitter Icon
  • Black YouTube Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon

Staff

Editor in Chief: Kaia Mann
kaiacolleenmann@gmail.com

Managing Editor: Astrid Cortez
astrid.corte921@gmail.com

Photo Editor: Taylor Cowhey
TaylorCowhey@outlook.com

Online Editor: Daimler Koch
daimlermkoch@gmail.com

Advisers

Professor William Dauber
dauberwj@lavc.edu

Professor Brian Paumier 
paumiebj@lavc.edu

Mission Statement

THE VALLEY STAR News is the independent student media outlet of Los Angeles Valley College. The Valley Star News is a website (including its social media platforms), a general-circulation broadsheet, and a magazine (The Crown) that serves as a laboratory for the journalism/photography programs and a bulletin board for the campus community. It is subject to the protections and limitations of the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. The highest standards of responsible and ethical journalism always apply, as do the libel laws of the land.

The Star News is first and foremost a campus media outlet. This must be reflected as much as possible in its coverage. Its mandate is to represent and inform the student body of Valley College. It reflects the interests of that community in all areas – campus news, current events, politics, sports, arts, entertainment, and more.

bottom of page